Zachariah - the Bombshell who arrived at the end of the first show - spends the day getting to know the girls as the Islanders play the first challenge of Wary Tales. First the Islanders appear through the window of a magic castle, then they burst through a drawbridge door and belly slide down a slippery slope, grabbing a golden key on the way. Then they choose a book to open which reveals a secret about another Islander - they then have to guess which Islander the Wary Tale is about and give that person a snog. The girls win the challenge - in the evening, the Islanders gather round the fire pit and Zachariah has to pick which girl he wants to couple up with.